If viewers were shocked by the first person to be voted out of Survivor 47 on Wednesday’s two-hour premiere on CBS, they weren’t alone. So was the host. It appeared that Andy Reuda would be the first booted after the AI research assistant from Brooklyn suffered from heat exhaustion at the challenge and called out his tribe mates for not liking him.

The host and executive producer also unpacks Andy mid-challenge medical situation, and his post-challenge meltdown.

Nothing is ever certain in Survivor, but host Jeff Probst says that Season 47 has uniquely unpredictable alliances.